Movies | Music | Masti Close Aha Ad
Movies | Music | Music

Ragalahari
ADVERTISEMENT

Debate: Should highest-grossing Indian movies list embarrass us?

ADVERTISEMENT

Recently, a film commentator named Ankit Jhunjhunwala took potshots at mainstream commercial Indian cinema’s quality. Quoting a list of India’s highest-grossing films (such as Dhurandhar, Pushpa 2, KGF 2, Jawan, Pathaan, Animal), he wrote that non-Indians can’t grasp how dominant this style is. He compared it to a hypothetical US where Steven Seagal’s lowbrow action movies top both the box office and the Oscars. He implied that Indian mainstream hits prioritize mass-appeal spectacle, melodrama, and star power over critical or artistic merit.

This criticism comes in the context of ultra-violent movies with lots of bloodshed becoming huge grossers. Matthew P, a Western audience member, wrote that Nani's The Paradise (it was no hit, but is representative of the trend Indian cinema has taken to) features "unbelievably graphic levels of violence despite cartoonish fighting". He added, "Some of the kills were astonishing and the cruelty mindblowing. You Indians have strong stomachs, and these are nearly 3 hour films. Do you take the family to see this?"

"I would rather be forced to watch Avengers Endgame for six months straight than voluntarily watch an Indian movie," Dr WomenHateShortMen remarked.

Indian cinema fans disagree with the framing. "The difference between Bollywood and Hollywood is that the former has zero qualms giving the audience exactly what they want with zero subversion or pretense of artistry," Chuck Sneedsman wrote. "We may be marginally worse on this front but a sizable portion of Oscar winners and highest-grossing Hollywood films are also pretty abysmal. Not exactly guarantors of quality in the West either," another movie buff countered. "American mainstream commercial cinema is a bunch of people playing dress up in front of a green screen. That’s supposed to be a superior level?" a Twitter user asked. 

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT